Two Kinds of Credibility
Last week I was working with a student on an image, and he kept hesitating on his adjustments. “I want it to look credible,” he said.
That word stopped me. Credible to whom?
The Two Kinds of Credibility
Here’s what I’ve come to understand about credibility in photography:
1. There are two definitions. One is faithfulness to what the scene literally looked like. The other is faithfulness to what you felt about the scene. Only one of these leads to art.
2. Cameras are mostly inept. They have no feeling, no emotion. They’re recording devices that capture light entering the lens. That’s all.
3. The camera placement, the arrangement, the perspective—that’s your artistic input. That’s uniquely yours. Someone else doesn’t place the camera the same way.
4. Don’t edit for “believability.” Edit for what you saw and felt. Credibility is limiting; vision is open-ended.
5. Ansel Adams rendered Half Dome in black and white. Nobody who visits Yosemite sees it that way. But nobody questions his credibility as an artist. He wasn’t documenting—he was expressing.
6. Editing should emphasize and strengthen what you already saw when composing. You’re not adding something false. You’re completing what you started in the field.
7. Your adjustments should be transparent, but not for “realism.” The goal is depth, mood, atmosphere. When viewers don’t notice your processing, it’s not because you held back—it’s because everything serves the feeling.
8. Art is what you saw that others didn’t. Anyone can document. Only you can show us what resonated with you.
9. You, and only you should decide what counts as authentic to you. Honesty and integrity should serve what’s most meaningful for you. If you’re willing to sign your name with integrity on your artwork, then that’s the purest sign of credibility I can think of.
All of this rests on one thing: something moved you to press the shutter. That emotional connection—whatever sparked your curiosity—is what every step serves. The composition, the editing, the printing… they’re not about manipulating a file. They’re about honoring the story you want to tell with your images.
Stay Connected
If this way of thinking about photography resonates with you, I share ideas like this in my free newsletter. No spam, no sales pitches — just honest thoughts on seeing, creating, and growing as a photographer. You’ll also get a free guide on my composition framework you can put to use right away.